Lecture #2: Mapping functional interactions in the connectome with fMRI
R. Cameron Craddock, PhD Research Scientist VI, Nathan S. Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research, New York, NY Director of Imaging, Child Mind Institute, New York, NY
July 29, 2014
Overview of MRI
Spinning hydrogen protons have a magnetic moment (\(\mu\))
At room temperature protons will align to an external magnetic field (\(B_0\)) to produce a net magnetization of roughly 3 ppm * \(\mu\) per Tesla
Hydrogen protons in a magnetic field precess at the Larmor frequency (\(f=42.58\,Hz/T\))
Protons can be flipped away from \(B_0\) using a RF pulse centered at the Larmor frequency allowing their magnetic field to be measured using a receiver coil (antenna)
Protons will return to aligment with \(B_{0}\) with a time constant \(T_1\)
The magnetization perpindicular to \(B_{0}\) will dephase with a time constant \(T_{2}^{*}\) due to diffusion and variations in the magnetic field
Spatially varying magnetic fields (gradients) can be used to encode a spin's position in the frequency of its rotation
Mapping functional interactions with fMRI
fMRI depends on \(T_{2}^{*}\) contrast
An fMRI time-course is formed by the rapid acquisition of MR images that are sensitive to the "blood oxygen level dependent" (BOLD) contrast
Hemoglobin, the protein which transports oxygen in the blood, contains four heme molecules, each with an atom of iron
Deoxy-hemoglobin is paramagnetic and creates a magnetic gradient that dephases the MRI signal
Oxy-hemoglobin is diamagnetic and does not affect the MRI signal
Hemodynamic response
R.B. Buxton, NeuroImage 62 (2012) 953-961.
It is not know for certain how the hemodynamic response is triggered or the phsyiological mechanisms behind its shape, but a model is emerging from experimental evidence.
Initially neurons begin firing in response to a stimulus and consumes locally stored metabolites and oxygen, increasing the amount of deoxy-hemoglobin which decreases the MR signal
The body is instructed to increase blood flow to the area (via astrocytes?)
The rate of extraction of oxygen from blood (and oxygen metabolism) is slower than the blood flow, resulting in a net increase in oxygenated blood, and a MR signal increase
After neuronal activity ceases, the signal returns to baseline after a brief undershoot
fMRI Data
fMRI data are acquired using \(T_{2}^{*}\) weighted gradient-echo EPI sequences
The optimal \(T_{E}\) for BOLD is 45ms at 1.5T and 30ms at 3T
Spatial resolution is typically ~ \(3 \times 3 \times 3 mm^3\)
\(T_{R}\) depends on the number of slices acquired (~ 60ms per slice) ~ 120mm typically needed to cover entire brain, 40 slices, \(T_{R} \approx 2500ms\)
fMRI Experiment
Finger tapping experiment.
Resting State Functional Connectivity
Biswal et al. MRM 1995.
Intrinsic activity is "ongoing neural and metabolic activity which is not directly associated with subjects’ performance of a task" - Raichle TICS 2010
Intrinsic Connectivity Networks
Functional Connectivity Analysis
A "typical" resting state FC experiment comparing two groups
Data are preprocessed to make the comparable across participants and to remove noise
Indiviudal level FC maps are generated for a seed region by correlating the seed time course with the time course of every other voxel in the brain
FC maps are compared between groups voxel-by-voxel using t-tests or ANOVAs
A note about structural images
Structural imaging data are used to calculate spatial normalizations and to derive tissue masks
The calucalated transforms will be used to spatially normalize fMRI data
The segmentation masks will be used to calculate noise regressors
Image is skullstripped to remove non-brain structure
Image is normalized to a standard template space using a highly-nonlinear (1000s of parameter) transformation
Image is segmented into white matter, grey matter, and cerebro-spinal fluid
Head motion is one of the most deleterious sources of noise in imaging
Motion during the acquisition of a slice will result in blurring, ghosting, and other reconstruction errors
Motion that occurs between the acquisition of slices will result in mis-registration of imaging volumes
The misalignment between images can be accounted for using coregistration algorithms.
Head Motion Correction - Intensity Modulation
Additionally head motion adds in intensity modulations due to partial voluming effects and spin history
These can be corrected by regressing models of motion from the dataset
6 motion parameters (Fox et al. 2006)
6 motion parameters, their squares, the parameters from the time before, and the squares of the previous parameters
scrubbing - delete frames near where head motion occurs
scrubbing regression - replace offending frames with mean
despiking - detect spikes and reduce them to a acceptable value
Signal Drifts
Throughout the course of the scan, as the gradients warm up, the MRI signal may slowly "drift"
These are not very strong in newer MRIs, but are noticable from time to time
These can be removed from the data by deterending, which models the drift as a low order polynomial and subtracts the fitted polynomial from the data
Physiological Noise
The brain pulses with the heart beat, which results in motion artifacts, and intensity modulations - can be measured in CSF and at saggital sinus
The rise and fall of the abdomen in the magnetic field induces global intensity modulations, and the changes in depth and rate of breathing result in changes to brain oxygenation level
Both of these noise sources can be modeled from recordings of heart rate (pulse oximeter) and respiration (repiratory belt), and regressed from the signal (PhysioFix, Retroicor)
Due to difficulties collected physio recordings in the scanner, the signal from white matter and CSF are commonly regressed from the signal to account for this variance
WM and CSF are determined using tissue masks derived from anatomical image
white matter is a surrogate for respiratory effects
CSF is a surrogate for heart rate effects
Can use multiple regressors that account for spatial variation in the signal (AnatIcorr, CompCorr)
Global signal is sometimes included as a non-specific surrogate for noise, but has become unpopular since it can introduce negative correlations
Nuisance Variable Regression
Previously discuss nuisance signals (\(\mathbf{\eta}\)) can be removed from the voxel time course (\(v[t]\)) using a regression model
The residuals of the model \(\nu[t]\) are the cleaned time courses
Bandpass Filtering
The resting state fMRI phenomenon is thought to be centered in the frequencies 0.001 Hz to 0.08 Hz, as a result it is common to apply a bandpass filter to the data to restrict the frequencies to this range
This doesn't remove much noise, because it is smeared throughout the frequency range
Many researchers now recommend to not use filtering, since their may be higher frequency information present in the data
Filtering should be performed after nuisance signal regression
Finally
Now that the data is de-noised it is ready to use
The data is written into standard space
Data is smoothed to improve correspondance between brains of different subjects